phlogiston was the wrong road

Categories: Comparisons

An historical example of metaphor and analogy in scientific writing:

"It may be divided, 1st, into the period of the alchemists, a lamentable epoch in the annals of intellectual wandering; 2dly, that of the phlogistic doctrines of Beccher and Stahl, in which, as if to prove the perversity of the human mind, of two possible roads the wrong was chosen; and a theory obtained universal credence on the strength of an induction, valid as such, but wrongly interpreted, which is negatived, in every instance, by an appeal to the balance."

Sir John Frederick William Herschel

Herschel, J. F. W. (1830). Preliminary Discourse on the Study of Natural Philosophy.

The alchemists were metaphorically wandering about.

Chemists had a choice of two roads and chose phlogiston theory, which was the wrong choice (implicitly the other road was the oxygen theory of combustion).

Read about analogy in science

Read examples of scientific analogies

Author: Keith

Former school and college science teacher, teacher educator, research supervisor, and research methods lecturer. Emeritus Professor of Science Education at the University of Cambridge.